For some, going to a high school reunion means catching up with old friends and reliving their glory days. But for others, the thought of seeing classmates for the first time in years fills them with fear and anxiety. Zaina was captain of her cheerleading squad in high school, but after 10 years, she considers herself most likely to not fit into her old cheerleading uniform. Even worse, she's worried that people will notice the difference in her appearance. "I am nervous that somebody might say something about my weight," she says. Joe, years removed from his "nerdy" high school days, is concerned that his classmates will think he's still a dork. "There were a few people who did tease me in high school," he recalls, "Called me a loser, called me a dork. I'm still very nervous about the reunion."

While Joe and Zaina are worried about what will happen when their former classmates recognize them, Rach's buddy Justin Willman attends the reunion with an entirely opposite agenda -- he wants people to recognize him -- which will be no easy feat since he didn't even go to their high school! Justin sets out to see if he can persuade the attendees that he was a fellow graduate, and to see if people will say they remember him just to save themselves the embarrassment of not remembering him.