A Twin Mac & Cheese "Rival Ray"

Aired on: June 22, 2011, January 10, 2011

Twins Melissa and Denise have more than looks in common; they also both love to make mac & cheese! But the women take opposite approaches to the dish, and each claims superiority in the kitchen. "Her mac & cheese is a carb overload!" says Denise of her sister Melissa's recipe. Denise cooks hers with an Irish lager to enhance the flavors, while Melissa favors wine. "I turned French onion soup into a macaroni & cheese," she says. "This is classy, winner all the way!"

Their family has tried both but refuses to pick favorites, so Melissa and Denise are asking Rach to settle this battle once and for all! Rachael invites another set of twin restaurant pros, Lisa and Debbie Ganz, to be the judges. The prize is bragging rights and the chance to see the losing sister wear a cheese suit on a NYC street corner carrying a sign that proclaims, "My Twin Makes Better Mac and Cheese!" Watch the video above to see who takes the prize! Plus, try their recipes for yourself: Melissa's French Onion Style Macaroni and Cheese and Denise's Irish Cheesy Beer Bake with Tomatoes.