Not only was "The Brady Bunch" such an iconic show, but the house and set where it filmed became legendary in its own right (the siblings are even recreating it on the new HGTV show, "A Very Brady Renovation"). So when all six Brady kids visited our show, we had to ask if they took anything from the original set over 40 years ago. 

While most of the Brady kids quickly denied it ("We were good kids! That would have been stealing!"), one sibling did come clean. 

"I took something," Maureen McCormick, who played Marcia Brady, admits, "which is very un-Brady-like." 

Marcia, Marcia, Marcia! (We had to.)

"But I have to say, I did ask the prop people if I could have it," she continues. "We did 'A Very Brady Christmas,' and there was this cute little wooden Santa that was hanging, and I was just like, 'I want that in my house every Christmas at home with my family.'"

And she still has it!

Now, Maureen's admission encouraged her "older brother" to come clean about something himself. 

"I waltzed off the set with the Hawaiian tiki — completely by accident, because I just happened to be wearing it and forgot to take it off," Barry Williams, who played Greg Brady, quips. 

(Suuure, Barry! 😉)