Three of your *American Idol* faves, Pia Toscano, Paul McDonald and Stefano Langone, are getting a second chance at the spotlight in a "Rival Ray" cook-off! • It was the "gasp was heard 'round the world" when fan favorite **Pia Toscano** was voted off the show. But she's back for a second shot at victory with her recipe for [Veggie Quesadillas](/food/recipes/pias-veggie-quesadillas/). "My skills aren't as good as they should be," Pia admits, "but I put a hundred and ten percent into everything!" • **Paul McDonald** loved taking the stage and rocking America during his run on the show, and he's hoping to rock the cook-off with his [Garlic Bread Grilled Cheese](/food/recipes/pauls-garlic-bread-grilled-cheese/). Paul jokes that his sandwich skills are what initially attracted girlfriend Nikki Reed: "She was like, 'I heard you cook ridiculously awesome grilled cheese sandwiches - we have to go on a date!' And I was like, 'Let's go! I'll make you some grilled cheeses!'" • "You're hot, I love you - that's all!" was praise **Stefano Langone** received from Jennifer Lopez, but will he feel the same love from the "Rival Ray" judges with his ["Fideo," a Mexican/Italian Mac and Cheese?](/food/recipes/stefanos-fideo-mexicanitalian-mac-and-cheese/) "I'm half Spanish, half Italian," Stefano says, "so you have to mix it up a little bit!" Watch the video above to see who judges Stephen Tyler, Jennifer Lopez and Randy Jackson (not *the* Idol stars, but people with the same names!) pick as the winner of the first-ever *Idol* "Rival Ray" cook-off!