The couple, who host "Nate and Jeremiah by Design" on TLC, has a "bone to pick" with Rach over the toy she got their daughter, Poppy, last Christmas. (Apparently, Rach inadvertently made their lives a little harder. LOL! )
Plus, Nate & Jeremiah entrusted our audience with settling one of their real-life home decor debates.
Watch it all play out in the video above!